Zolak & Bertrand: What should the Red Sox do with Marcelo Mayer?
On Wednesday’s edition of Zolak & Bertrand, the guys question whether they should deal for Marcelo Mayer.
Kristian Campbell could change the equation…
Tim McKone:
What do you do with Marcelo Mayer? Did you ride it through Milliken? What do you think?
Tyler Milliken:
I do think if you’re talking any of the prospects here and anyone who wants to call Marcelo Mayer a bust, I’m not saying John Tomase is doing that, but there has been some of that pushed out there that this guy is going to break down. At the end of the day, he tore up AA this year at 21 years old. He was leading the Eastern League in doubles. He hadn’t even played for a month until two days ago. So, while the power isn’t anything special, I don’t think he’s Bobby Witt Jr. or Gunnar Henderson or anything like that. I think he’s closer to a Xander Bogaerts. But what stands out about a guy like Xander Bogaerts, who was never the best shortstop in baseball, was the fact that he posted constantly with that durability. For a player like him that may not have the highest ceiling of, you know, a top five player in the sport, that really sticks out to me. I think when you talk about Roman Anthony, while maybe Baseball America and MLB Pipeline don’t have them as the number one guy in the system, there’s a reason does Sox Prospects. At 20 years old, he’s tearing up AAA right now. He looks incredible out there in his first 13 or 14 games, so I think he needs to be here no matter what. He’s not available in trades. Considering Connor Wong and how bad he looks defensively, I think that should tell you all you need to know about the Red Sox catching situation moving forward. He needs to be that guy hopefully in the next 12 months. And this is where now, it’s not a Big 3 anymore. It’s a Big 4 with Kristian Campbell with what he’s doing at AAA right now as well, tearing it up next to Roman Anthony. Unlike Mayer, who is also a lefty, Campbell’s a righty. He can play second base. You still have Trevor Story under contract for multiple years here. There is an infield you could put together of Story at short, hoping he stays healthy. Campbell at second with Rafael Devers at third and Casas at first, that could be pretty special. But if you’re going to talk about possibly moving a guy, yeah, I don’t think you rule Mayer out.
Listen to the full segment!