Integrity Matters: An apology to the South Shore bar pizza community

I’m sorry, bar pizza lovers. I got it wrong and want to make it right.
This isn’t the first time or the last that I mention this key thing regarding my articles I work so hard to craft: Integrity Matters! That’s why I’m here with you today.
Last year, I penned an article celebrating North Shore roast beef sandwiches. Unfortunately, I inadvertently overlooked some crucial details. My goal was to showcase beloved beef spots, but it seems I angered the roast beef community, especially in the “North Shore Beefs” Facebook group. I apologized for my misrepresentation, strive for greater accuracy in my future writing endeavors, and rewrote my definitive list of places to get a roast beef sandwich, updated list based on the votes from North Shore Beefs. Having personally tried these spots, I can attest to their top-notch quality and the unique scoring system the community employs.
Now, my focus shifts to another culinary delight that I may have overlooked: bar pizza.
South Shore’s bar pizzas are known for their affordable prices and delightful 10-inch size, featuring thin, crispy crusts that provide a satisfying crunch. The melted cheese adds a burst of flavor to every bite.
Deciding on the best bar pizza can lead to debates, with everyone having their personal favorite and sparking turf wars. It’s ugly in the south shore! But don’t worry—I’m here to right my wrongs and share my top (revised) picks for the best pizzas in town, including their respective websites, addresses, and phone numbers.
So, if you don’t have any plans this weekend, why not try a few of these places out!?
The definitive list of places for bar pizza around Boston and the South Shore
Here’s the definitive list of places to get bar pizza around Boston and the South Shore (in no particular order):
LYNWOOD CAFE
Burgundy bar stools, arcade games, and wood paneling. Lynwood Café has everything, including delicious bar pizza. Their ‘zas are famous enough to tempt folks from all over. They come for the local color, they come for the cheap beer, and they come for the pies topped with Boston baked beans.
CAPE COD CAFE
Cape Cod Cafe claims to be the original spot for South Shore bar pizza since 1939, as per their own story. They’re well-known for their mastery in this style and have four locations, with Brockton being the first. Their fame has reached nationwide, with frozen versions available for bar pizza fans missing home. Whether you’re a local or far away, Cape Cod Cafe is the go-to place for top-notch bar pizzas.
HOT BOX
Hot Box, located in Somerville’s Bow Market since 2018, specializes in takeout featuring North Shore-style roast beef sandwiches and a unique pickle pizza topped with hots. While some South Shore locals may see it as a trendy spot, Hot Box’s 10-inch pizzas stand out for their crispy perfection, competing with classic cheese pies and offering creative options like the Brunch #1 with eggs, bacon, and pepper gravy.
UNION VILLA
Family owned and operated, Buddy’s Union Villa holds the esteemed title of being Easton’s oldest bar and grill establishment. Since its inception in 1974, Buddy’s has remained steadfast in its commitment to serving the finest bar pizzas in the area.
TOWN SPA PIZZA
Town Spa is a big deal in the bar pizza world. It’s got a spacious, nostalgic vibe that reminds you of where your folks used to take the whole little league crew. After all these years, this family-friendly spot still rocks, even having a separate entrance just for takeout. They even do mail-order pizza now, which is awesome for folks who moved away from the South Shore. And let’s not forget their famous pickled pizza – don’t diss it till you’ve tasted it!
POOPSIE'S
Don’t miss Poopsie’s in Pembroke – a local gem satisfying South Shore residents since the ’70s. It’s so popular that you might have to wait for takeout during busy times. But it’s worth it for their bar pizzas with thin, crispy crusts and tasty toppings like feta and chili. Poopsie’s takes pizza seriously, so dive in and enjoy the deliciousness!
J’s FLYING PIZZA
J’s in Bridgewater has been a favorite among bar pizza lovers since the 1970s. Their specialty pizzas, like the taco pizza, blend perfectly burnt cheese with a crispy thin crust, creating an irresistible option for pizza fans.
HOEY'S PIZZA
Hoey’s, situated in a local American Veterans Post, is a fantastic spot for bar pizza fans. Their menu features a range of toppings like salami, anchovies, and more, catering to diverse tastes. If you’re craving something indulgent, don’t miss out on the Fat Daddy pizza, with double the dough, cheese, and sauce for an incredibly satisfying bite.
VENUS
The Venus, with locations in Marshfield, Whitman, and Hanson on the South Shore, is known for its fantastic bar pizzas, a real crowd-pleaser. They go the extra mile by offering gluten-free dough and innovative “sweet pizzas” topped with tempting combos like apple cinnamon and Oreo cookies, catering to all tastes, even those without specific dietary preferences.
TRADING POST LOUNGE
Being told by my friends in South Shore Bar Pizza Social Club that Trading Post deserves to be on the list! Okay! I’ve never been to this location, but based on the photos online, I don’t think I’ll be dissappointed!
NICK GEMELLI is a Producer on Toucher & Hardy, weekday mornings 6-10AM on 985 The Sports Hub. He is also a contributor on 985thesportshub.com. Follow Nick on X (formerly Twitter) at @NickGemelli.
CONNECT WITH TOUCHER & HARDY: linktr.ee/ToucherandHardy
For the latest, Visit the show page on 985thesportshub.com. Follow 98.5 the Sports Hub on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram! Visit our channels on Twitch and Youtube!