Zolak & Bertrand

Zolak & Bertrand

Zolak & Bertrand

One of the most memorable things on a baseball field is when emotions overflow and a brawl breaks out as the crowd frenzies. Just the last two decades of Red Sox fandom have brought some of the most legendary shoving matches in the sport’s history.

None of these brawls touch the infamous 1984 battle between the Padres and Braves, where fans got involved and it became the longest struggle ever on a baseball diamond. Still, something about Jason Varitek shutting Alex Rodriguez up has just as big of an impact.

Some players shy away from trading blows with other teams. Mookie Betts is always one of the first players that comes to mind after he declared that he was a lover and not a fighter back in 2018. Let’s just say the likes of Joe Kelly are on the opposite side of the spectrum, who don’t fear that confrontation one it.

I’d also throw Pedro Martinez into that category as well. He never feared pitching inside, even if it meant a fist was coming in high and tight towards his head a few innings later.

Feels like tempers very rarely reach the levels of some of the brawls even 10 years ago, because of how aggressive umpires act today. If there’s even an inclination of retaliation or some type of feud playing out, usually the pitchers is thrown out in seconds. Terry Collins knows that better than anyone, after Home Plate Umpire Tom Hallion explained that his ass was in the jackpot.

Just a heads-up, none of these rankings are listing one brawl over the other. This is just a collection of the Top 8 brawls in the history of the Boston Red Sox. If we missed any or you have a good submission, don’t hesitate to send them over on Twitter (or X?).

  • 1. August 11th, 2009 – Red Sox vs. Tigers

     

    Nobody knew when Kevin Youkilis and Rick Porcello decided to clash, that Porcello would end up being a key figure for the franchise from 2015-2019 and help bring home a World Series. Both were immediately ejected after wrestling on the ground, but I’m pretty sure that everyone is still surprised that a young Porcello was able to throw Youkilis around. It all started with Junichi Tazawa hitting Miguel Cabrera the night before.

  • 2. June 5th, 2008 – Rays @ Red Sox

     

    Arguably one of the most satisfyingly brawls in the history of baseball, as Coco Crisp dodged James Shield like he was in the Matrix before landing a right hook. This feud sparked after Joe Maddon claimed that Crisp tried to intentionally hurt Akinori Iwamura on a slide the night before. Both were immediately tossed, along with Jonny Gomes who threw a few punches at Crisp while he was still on the ground.

  • 3. August 29th, 2000 – Red Sox @ Devil Rays

     

    As I mentioned above, Pedro Martinez never had an issue throwing inside or at someone to prove a point. In this case, it led to Gerald Williams putting him on his ass pretty quickly to start the game. Still, Martinez wasn’t ejected like Williams and several of his teammates, which set the stage for the legendary right-hander to toss a 1-hit shutout at Tropicana Field.

  • 4. April 11th, 2018 – Yankees @ Red Sox

     

    Joe Kelly Fight Club was one of the biggest calling cards of the 2018 season. After Brock Holt was spiked by Austin earlier in the game and benches clear, Kelly wasted no time getting his revenge in the 7th inning. It was the realest the Red Sox-Yankees rivalry had felt in quite some time.

  • 5. July 24th, 2004 – Yankees @ Red Sox

     

    One of the most hyped moments in Red Sox history was when Jason Varitek finally shut up Alex Rodriguez with his catcher’s mitt. This was the peak of the Red Sox-Yankees rivalry and the game’s finish was just as electric as the brawl, with Bill Mueller hitting a walk-off 2-run homer against Mariano Rivera. Many look at this game as when the magic started for “the idiots.”

  • 6. October 11th, 2o03 – Yankees @ Red Sox

     

    Red Sox and Yankees were tied at 2-2 in the 2003 ALCS, with Pedro Martinez on the mound and in typical fashion, he had no issue throwing at Karim Garcia. With tempers running high, Garcia was mouthing off on the basepaths, before Martinez starting getting into it with Jorge Posada in the Yankees dugout. In the bottom half of the inning, Roger Clemens misses with a pitch up and Manny Ramirez starts walking towards the mound before chaos ensues.

    Seconds later, Martinez defends himself against a charging Don Zimmer, throwing the 72-year-old bench coach on the ground. In the following days, Zimmer apologized to the entire Yankees organization. Somehow there were no ejections in the entire game.

  • 7. May 20th, 1976 – Red Sox @ Yankees

     

    Back in the time machine to the days when a runner could collide with a catcher, Calrton Fisk and Lou Pinella got into a wrestling match after the two collided on a bang-bang play at home. Ultimately, the benches and bullpens emptied, with Bill Lee suffering a broken collarbone. One of the most heated moments in the Red Sox-Yankees rivalry.

  • 8. July 8th, 2011 – Orioles @ Red Sox

     

    While there were more punches thrown in the previous brawls, David Ortiz charging the mound after lifting a ball to center field always stands out. If Ortiz had landed his uppercut, Gregg might’ve ended up flying over the Green Monster. It left Ortiz and Gregg both getting ejected, alongside Jim Saltalamacchia and Jim Johnson.

Sign me up for the 98.5 The Sports Hub email newsletter!

Get the latest Boston sports news and analysis, plus exclusive on-demand content and special giveaways from Boston's Home for Sports, 98.5 The Sports Hub.

*
*
By clicking "Subscribe" I agree to the website's terms of Service and Privacy Policy. I understand I can unsubscribe at any time.